Confirmation Bias in Media: The Echo Chamber Challenge

Confirmation bias in the media skews the news.

Fuelled by con­firm­a­tion bias and media logic, echo cham­bers expose news audi­ences mainly to rein­for­cing opin­ions, nar­row­ing and dis­tort­ing their worldview. 

These phe­nom­ena hinder crit­ic­al think­ing, pro­mote mis­in­form­a­tion, and con­trib­ute to soci­et­al polarisation.

Confirmation bias is a con­stant chal­lenge for PR professionals.

Here we go:

Confirmation Bias in the News Media

Cognitive bias in the media presents a sig­ni­fic­ant issue because it can skew the present­a­tion and inter­pret­a­tion of news, lead­ing to a dis­tor­ted under­stand­ing of events and issues among the public. 

“Confirmation bias, the tend­ency to con­sume news that con­firms pre-exist­ing atti­tudes and beliefs, can con­trib­ute to the spread of false news on digit­al plat­forms.”
Source: Digital Journalism ¹Ling, R. (2020). Confirmation Bias in the Era of Mobile News Consumption: The Social and Psychological Dimensions. Digital Journalism, 8, 596 — … Continue read­ing

When media con­tent is influ­enced by biases — such as con­firm­a­tion bias, sen­sa­tion­al­ism, or media logic — it tends to favour cer­tain nar­rat­ives or per­spect­ives, often at the expense of a bal­anced and com­pre­hens­ive view. 

This select­ive rep­res­ent­a­tion can rein­force pre-exist­ing beliefs among audi­ences, con­trib­ut­ing to the polar­iz­a­tion of pub­lic opin­ion. It also hampers crit­ic­al think­ing, as people are less exposed to diverse view­points and more likely to accept biased inform­a­tion as truth. 

“Confirmation bias is a cog­nit­ive bias in which indi­vidu­als tend to focus on inform­a­tion that sup­ports their exist­ing beliefs, while over­look­ing con­tra­dict­ory inform­a­tion.”
Source: Encyclopedia of the Sciences of Learning ²Barry, P., & Tribe, L. (2009). Confirmation bias. Encyclopedia of the Sciences of Learning. https://​doi​.org/​1​0​.​1​0​0​7​/​978 – 1‑4419 – 1428-6_2086

Confirmation bias in media report­ing can per­petu­ate ste­reo­types and mis­in­form­a­tion, influ­en­cing pub­lic opin­ion and policy decisions based on incom­plete or skewed information. 

In an era where media plays a cru­cial role in shap­ing soci­et­al dis­course, cog­nit­ive biases under­mine the cred­ib­il­ity and trust­wor­thi­ness of media out­lets. It poses a broad­er chal­lenge to informed decision-mak­ing and demo­crat­ic pro­cesses in society.

Confirmation bias, amp­li­fied by social media algorithms and media logic, segreg­ates online com­munit­ies into isol­ated inform­a­tion bubbles — echo chambers. 

Learn more: Confirmation Bias in Media: The Echo Chamber Challenge

Echo Chambers on Digital Platforms

Echo cham­bers, amp­li­fied by con­firm­a­tion bias and media logic, pose a sig­ni­fic­ant soci­et­al prob­lem. They cre­ate envir­on­ments where indi­vidu­als are exposed primar­ily to opin­ions and inform­a­tion that rein­force their exist­ing beliefs, lead­ing to a nar­row, often dis­tor­ted worldview. 

“Echo cham­bers in social media con­trib­ute to the vir­al spread of mis­in­form­a­tion by act­ing as ini­tial band­wag­ons for com­plex con­ta­gions.”
Source: PLoS ONE ³Törnberg, P. (2018). Echo cham­bers and vir­al mis­in­form­a­tion: Modeling fake news as com­plex con­ta­gion. PLoS ONE, 13. https://​doi​.org/​1​0​.​1​3​7​1​/​j​o​u​r​n​a​l​.​p​o​n​e​.​0​2​0​3​958

In echo cham­bers, crit­ic­al think­ing and expos­ure to diverse per­spect­ives are lim­ited, which can con­trib­ute to spread­ing mis­in­form­a­tion and entrench­ing extrem­ist views. ⁴Silfwer, J. (2018, August 6). How To Fight Populism. Doctor Spin | The PR Blog. https://​doc​tor​spin​.net/​h​o​w​-​t​o​-​f​i​g​h​t​-​p​o​p​u​l​i​sm/

“Echo cham­bers are not just spaces where opin­ions are excluded, but also spaces where beliefs are rein­forced, con­trib­ut­ing to mis­in­form­a­tion and col­lab­or­at­ive res­ist­ance.”
Source: Episteme ⁵Elzinga, B. (2020). Echo Chambers and Audio Signal Processing. Episteme, 19, 373 — 393. https://​doi​.org/​1​0​.​1​0​1​7​/​e​p​i​.​2​0​2​0​.33

Such isol­a­tion can intensi­fy ideo­lo­gic­al polar­isa­tion, dimin­ish­ing the oppor­tun­ity for con­struct­ive dia­logue and under­stand­ing between dif­fer­ent groups. 

Echo cham­bers can under­mine the demo­crat­ic pro­cess by cre­at­ing frag­men­ted pub­lics, each with its own ‘facts’ and inter­pret­a­tions, mak­ing con­sensus and col­lab­or­at­ive prob­lem-solv­ing increas­ingly challenging. 

“Echo cham­bers and epi­stem­ic bubbles are dis­tinct social epi­stem­ic phe­nom­ena, and address­ing them requires dis­tinct inter­ven­tions.”
Source: Episteme ⁶Nguyen, C. (2018). ECHO CHAMBERS AND EPISTEMIC BUBBLES. Episteme, 17, 141 — 161. https://​doi​.org/​1​0​.​1​0​1​7​/​e​p​i​.​2​0​1​8​.32

Learn more: Echo Chambers: Algorithmic Confirmation Bias

Media Relations: Debiasing Techniques

“Debiasing tech­niques against con­firm­a­tion bias could poten­tially pro­mote human wel­fare by redu­cing ideo­lo­gic­al extrem­ism and fos­ter­ing under­stand­ing among diverse groups.”
Source: Perspectives on Psychological Science ⁷Lilienfeld, S., Ammirati, R., & Landfield, K. (2009). Giving Debiasing Away: Can Psychological Research on Correcting Cognitive Errors Promote Human Welfare? Perspectives on Psychological … Continue read­ing

As a PR pro­fes­sion­al work­ing with the media, employ­ing debi­as­ing tech­niques is cru­cial to ensure bal­anced and accur­ate com­mu­nic­a­tion. Here are sev­en such techniques:

Implementing these debi­as­ing tech­niques in your daily PR prac­tice can sig­ni­fic­antly improve the accur­acy and fair­ness of your media rela­tions, fos­ter­ing great­er under­stand­ing and redu­cing con­firm­a­tion bias.

Confirmation Bias in Organisations

Confirmation bias exists every­where, not just in the media. Organisations them­selves could bene­fit from being vigil­ant against biases influ­en­cing vari­ous intern­al com­mu­nic­a­tions practices:

PR Resource: Media PR Course

Spin Academy | Online PR Courses

Doctor Spin’s PR School: Free Media PR Course

Elevate your pub­lic rela­tions skills with this free Media PR Course—a must-have resource for all aspir­ing pub­lic rela­tions pro­fes­sion­als. Boost your career now!

• Media Logic is Dead, Long Live Media Logic
• The Shannon-Weaver Model of Communication
• The Electronic Age and The End of the Gutenberg Galaxy
• Social Media Logic: The Amplification of Media Effects
• Confirmation Bias in Media: The Echo Chamber Challenge
• Echo Chambers: Algorithmic Confirmation Bias
• The Hostile Media Effect: How We Demonise the News Media
• The Spiral of Silence
• Conversion Theory: The Disproportionate Influence of Minorities
• Information Asymmetry: The Informed Minority Advantage
• The Bandwagon Effect: Momentum Is Everything
• The Media Polarisation Model

Learn more: All Free PR Courses

💡 Subscribe and get a free ebook on how to get bet­ter PR ideas.