The owls are not what they seem.
After watching season 3 of Twin Peaks, I felt empty and dissatisfied as a fan for many years. So many side stories left unanswered — Audrey Horne’s story especially.
And Dale Cooper’s failure to defeat Judy, the ultimate evil? Ouch.
A few days passed, and little by little, two questions started to form in my head:
Let’s dive right in:
“Lucy Brennan is No Dimwit”
And out of all the characters, the lovely Lucy Brennan sparked my interest.
In the finale, Lucy accepts that there are two Coopers (one good, one bad) based on a brief telephone call with the real Dale Cooper. To me, this made no sense.
Bear in mind that Lucy has severe difficulties with the concept of how cell phones work (let alone the idea of doppelgängers) — but still, she immediately picked up a gun (she’s not a violent person, mind you) to blow Mr C (the evil Cooper) away.
Was this just sloppy storytelling?
As a character, Lucy would only use a gun to hurt someone if she knew that that person had severely hurt someone she loved. As a devote Lucy fan, I knew that that just had to be true. She’s no dimwit.
If so, here’s the question that sparked my Twin Peaks theory:
An Actor To Play a Devoted Son
Above all else, Lucy and her husband, Andy Brennan, love their son — Wally Brando. The third season of Twin Peaks did go to great lengths to demonstrate their love. Wally only made one appearance on the show, but gosh, what an appearance he made!
Wally, who shows up on his motorbike, is inspired by Marlon Brando, which is quite the cliché for a Lynch/Frost character.
For some reason, Wally must pay his respects to Sheriff Truman in a mannerism that could only be described as an attempt at acting out a bad script.
Why, why, and why?
The Fake Photograph on Lucy’s Desk
In one of Lucy’s earlier scenes in the third season, we see a photograph on her desk portraying her family.
Except it’s a family with poorly made cutouts of their heads, thus suggesting that something is seriously false about their family — something that Lucy and Andy apparently can’t deal with.
We know Mr C wreaked havoc in Dale Cooper’s absence, right?
What if Mr C killed Lucy’s and Andy’s real son? However terrible this thought is even to consider, it does add up:
Lucy stopped evolving. Unable to cope, Lucy would repress her memories and find it even more difficult to evolve with the times. She did struggle to cope with technology — she never understood the concept of cell phones despite 25 years of working as a receptionist.
The bad acting. To help, the original Sheriff Truman hired an actor to play Lucy and Andy’s son. The narrative: Wally’s out and about experiencing amazing adventures and loving his parents very much — but still, he’s being so weird and distant in their presence.
Time to clean out their dead son’s room. The first Sheriff Truman then charged the second Sheriff Truman to manage the situation, ensuring that Wally paid his “parents” the occasional visit. This meeting aims to allow Lucy and Andy to clean Wally’s room. Have they kept it as a shrine?
Sheriff Truman shakes his head. “Wally” is not Lucy and Andy’s natural son, just an aspiring actor (and not a superb one) trying to earn a few extra bucks now and then. But despite the awkwardness, you can see how Sheriff Truman and “Wally” are taken aback by the seriousness of the situation.
Deep down, Lucy knows the truth. Right after Lucy shot Mr C, she understood how cell phones work, indicating that she was back to her senses. And deep down, I suspect, she knows her son is dead.
I watched the Wally scene again with this new theory in mind. And it convinced me:
Hypothesis: Mr C Killed Lucy and Andy’s Real Son
Suddenly, every line of dialogue in the Wally scene seems brimmed with unspeakable pain behind Lucy’s and Andy’s smiling faces. As I’m watching this scene again, it stands out as one of the darker scenes I’ve ever seen on television.
And the scene beautifully foreshadows Lucy’s bold actions in taking out Mr C, the most central of the dark characters in the season. 1The fan thread on Reddit has people suggest that Wally Brando is an actor, too. However, this theory isn’t well-received; most fans seem to find it too dark—but no one asks how the real Wally … Continue reading
If I had been so wrong about Wally Brando the first time I watched season 3, I had to ask myself:
I had to go over it all again.
“What Year is This?”
So, what did I think happened in the last episode? In the Twin Peaks season 3 finale, here’s what I first thought went down:
Dale has a plan, but it isn’t to defeat Mr C. and send him back. As events unfold, Mr C will be shot by Lucy, and the Guy with the Glove will punch out the BOB orb. Dale’s real mission in Twin Peaks is the key to his old room at The Great Northern; he plans to find the final piece of the puzzle and put his and Major Briggs’ original plan back into play.
Dale finds Philip Jeffries in his “non-existent” state, and Jeffries opens a doorway in the infinite time loop. Cooper travels back in time to save Laura Palmer from being murdered, but something happens, and she disappears. Cooper travels back, meets up with Diane, and together they travel to a portal per The Fireman’s cryptic instructions. They go through the portal, and in the alternate universe where they emerge, they find Laura with memory loss.
Cooper ignores the murdered man on “Laura’s” sofa, maybe because he understands that everything Laura does is on him, too, or because he got a bigger fish to fry; the evil Judy residing within Sarah Palmer, Laura’s mom. Cooper takes Laura to Sarah’s house, potentially to make sure that Laura destroys Judy. But neither Sarah nor Judy is there. Bummer.
By saving Laura, Cooper created an alternate timeline, and now he’s forever stuck there while Judy is still in the original timeline. Cooper slowly realises that he seems to have ended up in the wrong place by asking:
“What year is this?”
Game over. Judy wins. Laura screams in terror. The end.
But this doesn’t seem right, I think. Yes, this is wrong!
Laura: The Fireman’s Scream Weapon
I had to watch the Twin Peaks season 3 ending again:
At the end of the finale, all the lights going out in the Palmer residence suggest that both Dale and Laura succeeded in fulfilling their story arcs — by killing Judy.
Right before Laura screams, there’s a faint call, almost sounding as if Sarah is shouting “Laura” from afar (which she also shouts in the first season before meeting BOB).
Whatever this cue makes Laura remember, it makes her scream at the top of her lungs, completely knocking out all the electricity in the house.
If Judy was in the house, would this have killed Judy?
Yes. Yes, it would!
Here’s why: Laura was the Fireman’s weapon sent to Earth to kill Judy.
How does one kill Judy, the ultimate evil?
According to fan forums, Judy derives from jiào dé, Chinese for “to outshout.”
Perhaps that’s why Laura’s been screaming throughout the series — it’s her weapon against the ultimate evil; all her emotions are compressed into one devastating blow.
Sound and sound waves are recurring themes throughout the series. Maybe the kinship between sound and electricity as waveforms allows travel between worlds and be used as weapons?
We might be onto something here. Let’s dig deeper, shall we?
That Bug in Sarah’s Throat? Laura!
Did The Fireman foresee the coming of events and plant his weapon against Judy, i.e. Laura and her scream, on Earth?
It seems like he did. In the black-and-white episode, when humans accidentally punched a hole through dimensions using nuclear bombs, the Fireman did send a bug, and that bug crawled down Sarah’s throat the year before Laura was born, remember?
And this is probably why evil forces had Laura killed in the first place; after all, she was humankind’s only weapon against Judy.
With Laura dead, The Fireman had to orchestrate an elaborate scheme to outmanoeuvre Judy and her minions while at the same time guiding Cooper back in time to retrieve Laura at the exact right time.
Remember, Laura is the Dreamer
In the final episode of season 3, Dale and Diane didn’t travel to another timeline but rather into Laura’s dream.
It has been suggested that the Laura that Cooper and Diane go to find is an alternate timeline version of Laura, but that theory doesn’t add up.
First, that would be lazy storytelling, and that’s not what Frost and Lynch are about.
Secondly, Laura gets her memory back in the final scene, which means that she is the real Laura, the Laura that Dale went back in time to save.
Two critical questions:
There’s a familiar sound before Laura vanishes into thin air in the forest scene. It’s the same sound The Fireman plays to Dale while clearly instructing him, “remember this sound.”
Alas, the Fireman, Laura’s creator, was the one who took her away from Cooper right there in the forest.
Complicated? Yes. Lynchian? Yes.
Let’s analyse Laura and Dale’s joint journey again:
Laura gets murdered by evil forces in Twin Peaks. Cooper manages to disturb these evil forces, but he is possessed by BOB, turning him into Mr C. The Fireman “saved” Cooper by keeping his mind with him for the next 25 years.
After 25 years, the time comes to deal the finishing blow to Judy. The Fireman reinstates Cooper into a doppelgänger, Doug.
After being disorientated for a while, Dale is sent back in time to save Laura from being murdered.
But then, right there in the woods, Laura is taken away by the Fireman.
Now, it’s Laura’s turn to be stashed away with a memory wipe for 25 years while everyone else’s life in Twin Peaks proceeds as if Laura’s body was never found. It explains why the diner in Laura’s dream version of Twin Peaks has the original sign still:
Being “tucked away” for 25 years, Laura wouldn’t know about the diner’s franchise efforts and thus wouldn’t know about the new sign. (We wouldn’t either if Lynch and Frost hadn’t shown us the story of Norma’s expansion plans.)
All of this must have been foreseen by the Fireman. Laura even told this to Cooper in a dream — “I’ll see you in 25 years.” Meaning: Cooper will get to see Laura again when he has saved her from being murdered and then, 25 years later, travels into her dream to meet with her.
Rather than solving her murder, it seems like Cooper succeeded in saving Laura Palmer’s life. Not bad, right?
“We Are Like the Dreamer Who Dreams”
“Dreaming” is a familiar Twin Peaks concept, and since electric signals in our brains create them, it makes sense for them to be more easily accessible to spirits.
Is it plausible to even think that the Fireman would have the power to put Laura inside a dream for 25 years?
The café scene with Gordon Cole states it clearly:
“We are like the dreamer who dreams and then lives inside the dream.”
Okay. Let’s go with the idea that Laura is the dreamer who lives inside her dream.
How 25 Years Passed in Laura’s Dream
When Dale wakes up alone and walks outside at the motel in Laura’s dream, the motel looks completely different. It seems as if 25 years had passed overnight.
And when he finally meets Laura, she’s 25 years older, too.
Let’s kill two birds (evils) with one stone (weapon):
The Fireman’s plan is audacious; have Dale travel back in time and find Laura (the stone), use her as a weapon against Judy (bird one), and close the portal in the Palmer residence to stop further evils from entering the real world (bird two).
But, this is the tricky part; the Fireman needs Judy to follow Cooper and Diane through the electric portal — and into Laura’s dream that Judy doesn’t know exists.
In short: Cooper and Diane must lure Judy into Laura’s dream.
How? Well, here’s how:
The Garmonbozia Lure to Trap Judy
At the motel in Laura’s dream, the night before the passage of 25 years, Dale and Diane have sex. Not passionate sex, but rather a dutiful and emotionally painful act, even.
And here’s the kicker:
Cooper and Diane must have sex, even though it pains Cooper to ask this of Diane. She does care for Cooper deeply, but it’s also reasonable to assume that she was previously raped by Mr C. Having sex with Cooper would force her to relive that pain.
The Fireman’s idea is that their shared pain, in combination with sex, will lure Judy to follow them into Laura’s dream.
Why is this painful act so irresistible for Judy?
Sex and pain are the ultimate nourishment for all dark forces in Twin Peaks, including Judy.
In the third season’s opening, we’re waiting to see a glimpse of the supernatural in a big glass box, but it isn’t until a couple has sex in front of it that a female shadow appears — and kills them.
Lodge spirits feed on human fear and suffering; the negative energy nourishes them … and it’s called Garmonbozia.
Garmonbozia is a golden substance that looks like creamed corn, and it’s mentioned in this scene from Fire Walk with Me:
Sex and pain seem typically linked to negative energy in Lynchian storytelling:
Both Laura and Ronette Pulaski were raped, too. If Mr C raped Diane — was she his only victim of sexual assault?
Which, of course, leads us to Audrey.
Waking Up: Audrey’s Comatose State
The idea of living inside dreams could also explain Audrey’s storyline. We know that she survived the explosion at the bank but that she ended up in a coma.
Let’s think about that for a second.
We never see Audrey wake up from her coma in the third season. We only get to see her living somewhere strange where Charlie guards her.
Perhaps Charlie is one of the Fireman’s “watchers” tasked with keeping an eye on Audrey? If so, Audrey’s entire season 3 storyline was inside her dream. Which, of course, would suggest that Audrey never woke up from the coma.
But what about Audrey’s son then, the mean-spirited brat Richard Horne? And this is where the darkness gives rise to more darkness:
If so, Audrey would still be dreaming in her unconscious state. A dream in which she’s gone just a little bit crazy — not unlikely, given her family history.
Also, nothing in Audrey’s “reality” seems to suggest that she’s living in an authentic, modern world — nor does she seem even aware of ever having (or losing) a son.
In her dream state, Audrey tries to get to the Roadhouse, a common portal in the world of Twin Peaks. She’s anxious and eager to get out of her state, but she, like Laura, must wait for 25 years before the Fireman’s timing is right.
At the Roadhouse, she must manifest Garmonbozia to “break the spell” — her sexy dance, the bar fight, and panic.
When she says to Charlie, which likely is her watcher commissioned by The Fireman, “Let me out of here!” she wants out of her comatose state.
And this is why Audrey, in her final scene, wakes up in a clinical environment wearing white — she’s just woken up at the hospital after being comatose for 25 years.
As it all comes together, a few remaining questions about Laura still need to be answered.
Who Answered the Door in Laura’s Dream?
So, let’s leave Audrey and return to the final scenes with Laura and Dale standing outside the Palmer residence inside Laura’s dream.
Judy is likely to have followed Cooper and Diane into the dream, a place “between two worlds”.
The woman who opens the door to Laura and Dale initially seems random. But two names are disclosed, Mrs Tremond/Chalfont. In Twin Peaks lore, those are not just random names; they are thought to belong to a generous lodge spirit. 2The woman who opens the door presents herself as Alice Chalfont. There are plenty of clues to suggest that she’s Mrs Tremond. She has changed her body once before in the series; some might … Continue reading
Maybe the Fireman had Mrs Tremond/Chalfont guard the portal or prevent Laura from returning through the portal during those 25 years? Perhaps they were “watchers” like Charlie, who was tasked with stopping Audrey from going to the Roadhouse too soon?
I think Mrs Tremond/Chalfont knew who Laura and Dale were when she opened the door. And I think she knew, as per the Fireman’s instructions, that Judy would soon appear in the house and that their sacrifice was nearing. After all, the good forces only had “one chance” for Laura’s scream weapon to do its job.
Except for Dale, who still seems confused. Why isn’t Cooper in tune with the exact details of The Fireman’s plan?
Well, the Fireman isn’t precisely known for speaking plainly. He’s a need-to-know type of character. He probably just instructed Cooper to go through the portal, have sex with Diane, and take Laura to her house — all of which he did.
What Happened in Twin Peaks When Laura Disappeared Instead of Being Found Murdered?
If my theory is true, what happened in Twin Peaks after Laura disappeared in the forest instead of being found murdered?
Well, Pete Martell didn’t find her lying dead and wrapped in plastic on the beach, but instead, Laura just vanished in the forest that night after her fight with James Hurley.
So, Leland Palmer never murdered Laura in the altered timeline.
Things would sure be “different”, as foreshadowed by Dale in his final visit to the Twin Peaks sheriff’s office. Not perfect, but a lot better without Judy — all thanks to Cooper, Laura, Major Briggs, and The Fireman.
If anything, I sincerely hope that Lucy and Andy’s real son is alive and well in the new version of Twin Peaks.
If two people ever deserved a good life, it’s Lucy and Andy!
The Fate of Coop, Diane, and Laura
It seems as if the Fireman has placed doppelgängers for both Cooper and Diane in Laura’s dream. Diane already saw her doppelgänger outside the motel and somehow figured out their names — Linda and Richard.
The Fireman mentioned Linda and Richard to Cooper early in season 3, so these doppelgängers are there per the Fireman’s design.
Since Diane’s doppelgänger was waiting for her at the motel, it’s plausible that Diane went out to speak with “herself” later that night when Cooper was asleep.
It’s fair to assume that Diane’s doppelgänger instructed her to write a note to Cooper with The Fireman’s second clue.
Finally, will Cooper, Diane, and Laura, with the aid of the Fireman, ever be able to return to the real world?
Dale doesn’t even know what year he’s in, he’s inside Laura’s dream, or Layra just killed Judy and closed the portal. He’s been in and out of lodges, dreams, and time loops for two consecutive quarters of a century now — he’s understandably a bit confused.
However, I’m not too worried.
Audrey was able to get back to the real world from her dream. And the dreams, despite being Laura’s in this case, seem to be supervised by the Fireman.
Bringing It All Together: The Lynch/Frost Way
Lynch and Frost show us that they can tell a story without editing out all the peculiarities because those idiosyncrasies are the stuff that matters.
After all, Lynch and Frost could’ve just brought Dale back in the first episode of season 3. But in this universe, travelling between worlds is no easy feat.
I understand now that not a single frame in Twin Peaks is out of place or superfluous — they all serve a central purpose for the plot.
I’ll leave you with a few words by David Lynch himself:
“Everybody has theories about what the show is about, which is great, and it wouldn’t matter if I explained my theory,” Lynch writes. “Things have harmonics, and if you’re true to an idea as much as you can be, then the harmonics will be there, and they’ll be truthful even though they may be abstract. You could come back in ten years and see it in a completely different way, and you may see more in it — that potential is there if you’ve been true to that original idea.”
|The fan thread on Reddit has people suggest that Wally Brando is an actor, too. However, this theory isn’t well-received; most fans seem to find it too dark—but no one asks how the real Wally would’ve died, then. On the point of darkness: Mr C wreaked havoc in Cooper’s absence, possibly raping and impregnating a comatose Audrey Horne (and thus spawning the disturbed Richard Jr) and possibly raping Diane. If that’s the level of darkness, Lynch went for, murdering Lucy and Andy’s son sure would fit the bill. Mr C’s crimes were unspeakable, so that Lynch could’ve decided to only hint at them as a storytelling device.|
|The woman who opens the door presents herself as Alice Chalfont. There are plenty of clues to suggest that she’s Mrs Tremond. She has changed her body once before in the series; some might remember her appearance when she was living next door to the unfortunate Harold. And she has a habit of having her name inspired by those who lived in her house before; it also happened with the name Chalfont in Fat Trout Trailer Park. She is a lodge spirit, but she was helpful to Laura and refused “creamed corn” delivered by Donna’s Meals on Wheels. So, assuming she’s prepared to help Laura defeat Judy is reasonable. But we know her grandson has a mean streak, so she pretends as if she doesn’t recognise Laura and Cooper.|